Joker - 5.5/10
A bleak, twisted, but still quite superficial origin story that will bend the image of the superhero movie for better and worse.
Since we can't talk about Joker without addressing the commentary surrounding it, no, I don't feel this movie is 'dangerous' as certain critics think. For Joker to be dangerous, it would need to have a coherent ideology. It's angry but unintelligibly so. Todd Phillips can't articulate any kind of stance on the surface level questions he raises. I also believe the incels that commentators fear this story empowers lack the self-awareness to identify with certain character traits of this Joker. I would still like to hear Phillips explain the reactions I experienced in the theater. What does he think when some audience members burst into applause at the first homicidal eruption? Should some in the audience be laughing at a mentally ill man completely breaking down? Are little people jokes still funny? What is the difference between being inspired by Scorcese and Lumet and outright stealing from their films?
You have to watch this thing through a thick Disney-fied Marvel lens to see it as shocking or perverse. It's really quite a huge drag the whole way through. Yes, the violence is sudden and vicious and no this is absolutely not a movie for kids. It seems though, that by shoehorning a 70's 'inspired' crime drama into a superhero adjacent studio picture, which after Joker I expect to be a standard practice, you can have the press calling it the most subversive piece of pop culture out there.
Phillips was lucky to get Joaquin Phoenix for a gritty character study. The man is the best actor working today. His portrayal of a mentally ill loser down and out in the slums of Gotham is captivating. The best moments are when Phoenix, the cinematographer, and the score are perfectly in-sync; the scenes capturing his movement in the apartment and bathroom, while unable to support an entire movie, are gorgeous pieces of filmmaking. The problem is and always would be the story. Todd Phillips doesn't have deep thoughts, only basic questions. The Thomas Wayne storyline is total trash. There wasn't even an attempt to write another interesting character so you have great actors like Zazie Beetz and Robert DeNiro with nothing to work with. Bill Camp and Shea Whigham have maybe three lines each.
We were told we would be shocked by the Joker. I left a bit shocked at how vapid it was.