Finally got a bottle of Smith and Cross to fuck around with. I feel like Antica probably would have been the better vermouth choice, but I'll figure that out later. Im actively trying to only keep one bottle of vermouth open at a time to maximize turnover and keep them fresh (and chilled Stabby). This Kingston Negroni is pretty, pretty good. Gotta find some more uses for this wild ass rum.




You don't know the half of it.Did your bottle of ango survive a shipwreck?
I have all of this, may need to try.

I find that the amaro makes a bigger difference. Can’t always get Amaro Nonino so I’ll swap in what I can find. That said, I also use 100 proof bourbons in cocktails.
Been on a paper plane kick with the weather, bonus points for my wife loves them. We aren’t huge cocktail people at home, but easy enough and I’ve enjoyed Eagle rare as the bourbon.
Anyone have some favorites or preference in this instance ? Does a higher proof work better or worse? Something fruit forward like four roses or nutty like a Beam product ?
I agree 100% that Nonino and Aperol are the important bottles here. For bourbon in Paper Planes I have used anything from Elijah Craig to Buffalo Trace to McKenna BiB and Evan Williams BiB. It didn't really change the enjoyment of the cocktail at all.I find that the amaro makes a bigger difference. Can’t always get Amaro Nonino so I’ll swap in what I can find. That said, I also use 100 proof bourbons in cocktails.
I think I have noted this elsewhere in this thread, but I prefer a sharper , more bitter Amaro than Nonino. A straight paper plane is easy to guzzle, and I need something to make me stop and think a bit more about each drink. Amaro della Sacra has been that one for me.I agree 100% that Nonino and Aperol are the important bottles here. For bourbon in Paper Planes I have used anything from Elijah Craig to Buffalo Trace to McKenna BiB and Evan Williams BiB. It didn't really change the enjoyment of the cocktail at all.
If I don't have Nonino, I don't make Paper Plane.